India’s ongoing Test struggles have reignited debate over Virat Kohli’s decision to step away from the format. In Guwahati, India’s first innings ended at a meagre 201, allowing South Africa to take a 288-run lead after their 489-run first innings. By the close of day two, India were 26/0 in their second innings, leaving little hope of avoiding defeat.
Former Indian cricketer Sreevats Goswami argued on social media that Kohli’s continued presence in Tests would have greatly benefited the team. He wrote: “Kohli should have left ODIs behind and continued playing Tests. His energy, passion, and ability to instill belief in teammates are qualities that Indian cricket is desperately missing.”
India’s batting woes were evident as young players struggled under pressure. Rishabh Pant, leading the line-up, failed to provide the stability and strategic guidance that Kohli could have offered. Mistimed shots, poor communication between batters, and lack of experience contributed to India’s dismal performance.
| Key Performance Metrics | India | South Africa |
|---|---|---|
| First Innings Score | 201 | 489 |
| Lead | – | 288 |
| Second Innings | 26/0 | – |
Analysts believe that Kohli’s leadership is not just about runs—it is about strategy, energy, and the psychological edge that inspires a team. The absence of such a figure in the longest format is clearly evident, especially in challenging overseas conditions.
India’s prior Test series loss to New Zealand and now the looming defeat against South Africa indicate that the team is struggling to find its footing in the absence of experienced players like Kohli. With a series at stake, the debate over whether India prematurely allowed him to retire from Tests has intensified.
Experts suggest that recalling Kohli could restore India’s balance, not only through his batting but by mentoring the younger players and providing a steadying influence under pressure. His presence could be critical in turning the tide for India’s flagging Test fortunes.
As the series continues, the central question remains: can India recover without Virat Kohli, or is it time to reconsider his Test retirement?